Welcome to Lighthouse Seafood
At Lighthouse Seafood, nestled in Hampton Bays, NY, we celebrate the bounty of the sea with an unwavering commitment to freshness and quality. Our storied tradition of sourcing local fish and shellfish connects us to the vibrant community of fishermen in the region. Customers rave about our signature lobster rolls, freshly shucked oysters, and delectable clams, all served by our friendly and knowledgeable staff. With a focus on exceptional service and unbeatable prices, we strive to create an extraordinary experience that brings the taste of the ocean directly to your table. Come visit us and relish in the epitome of seafood excellence.
-
36 Lighthouse Rd, Hampton Bays, NY 11946, United States Hotline: +1 631-728-5186
Welcome to Lighthouse Seafood, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Hampton Bays, New York. Located at 36 Lighthouse Rd, this seafood market offers a unique blend of freshness and flavor that is simply unmatched. With a commitment to providing the best quality seafood at reasonable prices, Lighthouse Seafood has carved out a special place in the hearts of both locals and visitors alike.
Unlike traditional restaurants, Lighthouse Seafood is a market where you can experience the bounty of the ocean while engaging with friendly and knowledgeable staff. The vibe here is undeniably casual and welcoming, making it a perfect stop whether you're coming in after a beach day or stopping by for a special occasion. Customers rave about the encounter with freshly prepared signature dishes like their lobster rolls, which are hailed as some of the best in the area. One satisfied patron, Joseph Buscemi, described it as “one of the freshest, most delicious lobster rolls” he’s ever had, a testament to the culinary expertise you can find behind the counter.
What sets Lighthouse Seafood apart is its commitment to quality and community. Many customers, like Matthew Raynor, a local fisherman himself, praise the market for sourcing seafood directly from local fishermen, ensuring maximum freshness and sustainability. Whether you’re looking for scallops, blackfish, or an array of shellfish, you can count on finding only the best at Lighthouse Seafood. As customer Adore Ehmewiz noted, it’s their top choice for seafood on the east end, reflecting not only in the product selection but also their dedication to customer service.
First-time visitors often leave feeling like regulars, thanks to the warm hospitality and attentiveness of the staff. From helping you choose the right cut of fish to expertly shucking little necks on the half shell, they go above and beyond to ensure a delightful experience. As Steve Behar shared, even special ordering for New Year's Eve turned out to be perfect, highlighting the excellent service provided.
If you're in search of a culinary adventure that brings the ocean’s best directly to your table, look no further than Lighthouse Seafood. With rave reviews for its diverse offerings and impeccable service, this seafood market truly shines as a must-visit destination in Hampton Bays. So the next time you're in the area, don’t just pass by—stop in, say hello to the team, and discover what the buzz is all about. Your taste buds will thank you!
Great fresh fish at best prices in the Hamptons. Go, get some. Put it on the grill at home. Way better than any restaurant done right at home.
Stopped in here after a beach day because we thought it was a restaurant. Its not, but the guys behind the counter asked if we wanted a lobster roll. What he made was one of the freshest most delicious lobster rolls ive ever had. Also split oysters clams and lobster salad. All top notch served by some of the friendliest staff ive come across.
So good! I ordered the oysters, shrimp, clams, & the lobster roll. I could have eaten everything a thousand times over! Sooo good. Do yourself a favor and stop in. The crew is amazing and will make sure you have a wonderful experience!
we still miss the days of Cor-J but fortunately little has changed and this is still our #1 choice for seafood on the east end best product/selection knowledgeable staff. they'll do #littlenecks on the halfshell (when we dont have time to shuck at home) it's a dream and reasonably priced. the blackfish was write-home-about level delicious
I have to say this place is a true gem. Ordered for NY Eve and everything was perfect! Delicious and fabulous service from Michael. I highly recommend this place. We will be back very soon! Thank you for being so terrific and making this such a great experience. Steve
Extremely fresh fish. I am a fishermen who sells his shellfish to this market. I sell clams and bay scallops along with fish when I work on the commercial boats. I can say it’s expertly ran and the fish are always fresh. As long it’s a native species of fish/shellfish which is in season they are from local fishermen. Basically brought right from Shinnecock to the display case in corjays. They are willing to help you in anyway possible and are friendly as long as you are respectful. Very honest hardworking folks. They’ve always paid me what is owed. Five stars
The seafood here is so fresh, I love buying all sorts of fresh fish here. Scallops , flounder, black sea bass are outstanding. There are so many fresh fish choices. Service is wonderful too.
Probably my most favorite fish market ever. You are up close and personal to many different options both in fish and seafood. Every item i have every body done with such freshness and hot. The product is very well taken cared of. And the staff is super cool, generous and patient. Plenty of parking. And on busy days, they manage to push the the clients thru but never once do you feel rushed. Amazing production. Thank you for all your service.